• Writing
  • About
  • Collaborate
  • Recipes
  • Search
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  •  

Baked, Brewed, Beautiful

Coffee Maker Vs French Press

in Brewed on 09/22/22

coffee maker at the top and french press on the bottom of pin

Learn whether a French press or a coffee maker is best for your home coffee brewing needs. It comes down to budget, simplicity & aesthetic.

Guest Post By: Helen Harper, editor of Stay Roasted

  • Two of the most popular ways of brewing coffee at home include a French press and a coffee maker.
  • French press coffee brewing is both inexpensive and an excellent travel companion due to its compact size.
  • Electric coffee machines are consistent and at the touch of a button can offer you a near perfect cup of coffee.
  • Deciding between the two types of coffee brewing depends on your budget and your desire for ease of use.

For most people, the day doesn’t start until they’ve had their morning coffee. Most adults love the kick that a shot of caffeine can provide. Because of this, there are 517 million cups of coffee consumed in the United States alone.


Thankfully, you don’t need to head into a café to get a quality coffee. With the right tools and a little know-how, you can make a barista-quality blend at home. There are two popular ways of doing this. You can either use a coffee maker or a French press machine. So, which option is right for you?

French Press

Let’s start by looking at one of the oldest ways of making coffee, with the design first being patented in 1852, though they didn’t start rising to prominence until the 1920s. These devices have been praised for their simple, yet delicious, approach. 

How it Works

The process of using a French press is super simple. First, you need to preheat the water. It should be between 195 to 205 Fahrenheit to extract the best possible flavor from the beans.  While you are waiting for the water to boil, you can weigh out the beans and start grinding them up. 

When the machine is hot enough, you can put in the grounds and the hot water. Place the lid on the French press and wait for the flavor to be extracted from the beans. This will often take around four minutes. 

When you are ready for your coffee, simply push down on the plunger. This will trap all the beans in the base of the device. You can then pour out the coffee and enjoy. This article has more tips on how to get the best possible French coffee. 

Advantages of the French Press

There are several reasons why people choose the French press. As we mentioned, one of the main attractors is how easy the process is. You should be able to get coffee within a few minutes. Unlike a coffee maker, there are no mechanical parts to worry about. All you need to do is wash the press out and you’ll be ready to use it again. 

metal French press next to a newspaper on a wooden table

If you are on a tight budget, the French press is the best approach. These machines tend to be fairly inexpensive. A cheaper model can be found for around $20. The top-of-the-line models should only cost you $150. This is significantly cheaper than other brewing methods, including the coffee maker. Furthermore, these devices are compact, allowing them to fit in a tight space. 

A third reason why people love the French press is that it is so easy to learn. The trickiest part will be finding the right grind size to deliver the flavor you want. Once you’ve mastered this, you’ll be able to enjoy consistently great coffee. 

Downsides of the French Press

But there are a few potential problems that a French press can pose. First, many other coffee makers will boil the water within the machine. You might even find a coffee maker that will grind the beans for you. On the other hand, when you are making a French press each of these steps will require its own machine. This can quickly clutter up your bench space. 

While you don’t need to be a barista to use a French press, it isn’t completely idiot-proof. You still need to monitor the amount of time the beans have been in the boiling water. Leave them too long, and you’ll be left with a bitter-tasting brew. 

When to Use a French Press

There are a few circumstances where a French press is most commonly used. First, if you have a limited budget, but you still want delicious coffee, this is the right choice for you. Its compact nature and ability to work without electricity make it a good pick for a camping trip. 

Coffee Maker

The coffee maker also has a long history, with designs first being patented in 1908. Over the years, they have gone through a wide range of changes to produce the sleek, modern devices that we have today. 

Types of Coffee Makers

There are many types of coffee machines to explore. For example, some will rely on you grinding up coffee beans. Others will use K-cups, which contain pre-ground coffee. You can have an espresso machine or drip. This article goes into more depth about the type of available coffee makers. 

With so many options it can be a little difficult to find the one that suits you best. It’s best to consider the number of people who will be using the coffee maker. For example, drip coffee can produce a pot of coffee, which is ideal for an office but might be overkill for one person. This list of coffee makers for your great coffee will help you find the right one for you. 

Advantages of a Coffee Maker

There are a few reasons why you might want to turn to a coffee maker. First, it will allow you to customize the brew. For example, you should be able to control how strong the coffee is by changing each part of the coffee-making process. You can create something that perfectly suits your tastes. Or you can use one of the pre-set functions. Many machines will allow you to save these settings.  Then, you’ll be able to get a beautiful cup of coffee with just the push of a button. 

Compared to the French press, there are more features in a coffee maker. For example, you might be able to get a heated plate that will keep the pot warm throughout the day. At other times, it will come with a self-cleaning function. 

Many of these machines will be able to get you a drink fast. Forget the four minutes you have to spend using a French press. Depending on the coffee maker, you can get a drink within a minute. 

Downsides of a Coffee Maker

Of course, nothing is perfect. There are a few potential downsides to using a coffee maker. First, they can be bulky, so you’ll need to make sure that you have enough benches to accommodate them. They can also be quite expensive. A basic model will cost a few hundred, though they can cost up to $5,000 for a top-of-the-line machine. 

The other big downside is that you will need to spend some time cleaning the machine. If you don’t, the minerals from the water will build inside the machine, which can start to affect the taste of your drink. 

When to Use a Coffee Maker

It’s best to invest in a coffee maker for your kitchen to make your daily cup of joe. It will give you a professional-grade beverage every time. Plus, it will get the job done fast, so you don’t have to wait for your daily dose of caffeine.  

How To Choose

Both a French press and a coffee maker are capable of delivering a delicious cup of coffee. The one you pick will depend on what you are looking for. If you value simplicity, a French press is the right choice. But if you are looking for something that will create barista-quality beverages that will please the fussiest coffee-lover. 

two small cups of coffee on a newspaper
The 5 Best Ways to Make Coffee While Traveling
french press coffee being poured into a mini mug next to a newspaper
Coffee Expert Reveals 5 Tricks For Making The Best After-Dinner Coffee
from top - view of pumpkin spice latte in a high ball glass with a blue background a small pumpkin and two ice cubes in the latte
Healthy Iced Oat Milk Pumpkin Spice Latte Recipe

Add a Comment

« 5 Mistakes You’re Making With Cold Brew Coffee
10 Unexpected Ways to Use Coffee Filters »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cheyenne Elwell

HI, I’M CHEYENNE.

Cheyenne Elwell, ASJA is a travel and lifestyle writer covering coffee culture, small towns, and slow travel. Her work explores how people experience place through everyday rituals like coffee, meals, and quiet moments. She has written for Business Insider and The Spruce Eats.

Read more →

AS SEEN IN
Business Insider The Spruce Eats
Baked Brewed Beautiful
Small Towns • Coffee • Wine
NEWSLETTER

Slow travel stories shaped by coffee, wine, and small towns.

Join the newsletter →

logo
Food Advertisements by

bakedbrewedbeautiful

Coffee, wine, food & places
For the endlessly curious 🤎
From my notebook to your next discovery
↓ Read the latest ↓

Cheyenne Elwell | Food & Travel Journalist
Send this to your wine-tasting partner. Choosing Send this to your wine-tasting partner.

Choosing where to taste next is easier when you know more than what the patio looks like. I’m a travel, food & wine journalist sharing what’s being poured, what makes a tasting experience stand out, and what I learn from the people behind it.

Follow along for ideas for your next outing, with a little more context before you book.

#WineLovers #WineTasting #WineCountry #FoodAndWine #BakedBrewedBeautiful
Most of us only meet wine once it’s already in t Most of us only meet wine once it’s already in the bottle.

But during harvest, even something as simple as leaves making it through sorting can affect what eventually ends up in your glass.

At @hawkinscellars, I got a closer look at how many small decisions happen before a bottle ever reaches the table.

It’s the kind of detail you don’t see on the label.

#WineHarvest #WashingtonWine #Winemaking #WineLovers #bakedbrewedbeautiful
I’ve spent the past year studying wine, but actu I’ve spent the past year studying wine, but actually getting my hands on the grapes was a completely different experience.

We tasted Pinot Noir that was still too acidic and “green,” which meant it needed a few more days on the vine. I knew harvest timing mattered, but actually tasting a grape that wasn’t ready yet made it click.

Then I spent a few hours sorting Grenache, pulling out leaves and anything else that shouldn’t make it into the wine. Thane told us the grapes were exceptionally clean, which I learned isn’t always the case.

I also finally got to watch a “mini punch-down” after reading about them in wine textbooks for the past year.

And now I’m hoping this story gets one more chapter. If Hawkins bottles the Grenache as a single-varietal wine, I may eventually get to taste a wine made from grapes I helped sort.

If you could spend a day behind the scenes at a winery, what would you want to see?

#WineEducation #Winemaking #WineHarvest #WashingtonWine #WineLovers
Fall cocktail menus are shifting, and some longtim Fall cocktail menus are shifting, and some longtime favorites aren’t getting the same love behind the bar.

I spoke with three bartenders about what they’re excited to pour this season and what they’re ready to leave behind.

One trend gaining ground? Savory cocktails, with unexpected ingredients making their way into the glass.

But that’s only one side of what’s changing behind the bar this fall.

I broke down 5 trends that are in and 5 that are out this season for Business Insider.

Read the full article at the link in my bio.

#FallCocktails #CocktailTrends #CocktailCulture #FoodAndDrink #Journalist
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com.
You can learn more about our affiliate policy here.

  • About
  • Writing
  • Collaborate
  • Recipes
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Disclaimer & Disclosure